Your future protected

Finding the best combination of insurance coverage and cost can be a daunting task. At Dexter & Rightmyer Insurance, we make the process simple, and explain coverages in terms you can understand, so you know exactly how your money is being spent.


Ratings from trusted customers

"Chris was awesome during the experience of contacting him for quotes about auto and renter's insurance! He has a great personality and is easy to talk to and ask him questions!"

"Chris is amazing at finding you affordable insurance coverage for all your needs. He recently helped us obtain a homeowner's policy for our new home and it was such an easy process and also at a great rate in comparison with multiple other company's. Would recommend him to anyone for there insurance needs!!!"

"I had a great experience with Chris. I found him through Dave Ramsey's list of ELPs in my area. He was extremely helpful and had a very affordable quote for my car insurance in no time. The coverage is wonderful and I'm thankful to have a good agent."

Dexter & Rightmyer Insurance is built on the bedrock principle of customer service.

We strive to give our customers the benefit of our years of experience and to give consumers the right answer to their questions, whether or not it results in the sale of a policy.


Why choose us?
We believe in strong customer service along with a few other core beliefs -

  • Effeciency

    Your time is valuable, so we work quick to deliver results.

  • Clarity

    Insurance can be confusing, we'll make it easy to understand.

  • Honesty

    When other agencies sell you what you don't need, we don't.

With Dexter & Rightmyer Insurance, you've got a plethora of insurance carrier & coverage options

Gone are the days of calling around from broker to broker trying to pin down the right coverage and an honest price. We understand your time is valuable, so we shop and compare top companies on your behalf so you don't have to stress.

Insurance is never just about price, but we deliver when it comes to saving you money

Because our agency is 100% independent, we have multiple options and can compare the best available policies for you. With flexible coverage and deductible options, we can find solid coverage for any budget. We routinely beat those companies you see on TV everyday by hundreds of dollars.

  • Average Annual
    Rate Reduction

We can create a coverage plan
specific for your unique needs

Personal Insurance

Whether it's homeowners, auto, boat, motorcycle or anything else, we can help.

Business Insurance

We insure hundreds of businesses of all shapes and sizes. 

Specialty Insurance

Our agency can also help with specialty insurance coverages.

Our process is simple

At Dexter & Rightmyer Insurance we don't skip to the quote, we dig and put together the best coverage policy for your money.

  • Start Online

    Enter some basic information on our website to start.

  • We Shop For You

    We shop multiple insurance carriers for you.

  • Pick The Best Plan

    Choose the coverage package that fits best.

We're here to help help make sense of insurance

Start a conversation with one of our insurance advisors.